A little touch of Spellborn in the night

Maybe I shouldnt have picked the thin setting

There is such a thing as too thin

The Chronicles of Spellborn (TCoS) is in beta at the moment, and I was bored … a dynamite combination. And so Spinks the Rogue Trickster was born.

Spellborn is a fantasy MMO, so you will be running around doing quests, killing boars, casting spells, crafting stuff, listening to other people noob it up on the zone channel, wondering what happened to your bag space, and all those other much beloved features that people expect to see these days.

The more unusual features, which I’m going to dwell on, are the combat, the immersive use of stats, and lack of gear dependence.

There are both PvE and PvP servers. On the PvP server, there are safe zones, but after you get out of the starter areas, it becomes more of a free for all.

And although I didn’t level up high enough for that, PvP in this game is going to require quick thinking and good observational skills, because there’s no way to tell what class/discipline an opponent is just by eyeballing them. You have to see what they do and then react.

So let’s start at the beginning

Character creation lets you pick between two different races: Human or Deva (a satyr-type demon). You can pick between three different builds, from skeletal thin (as in the screenshot above), athletic, and an adorable fat suit that I wouldn’t expect to be so popular. Although the temptation to make a Fat Bottomed Girls guild and only let fat characters in, and sing Queen covers as we roam the landscape cutting bloody swathes through our more svelte opponents is quite high.

You pick your base class from the three standard choices of warrior, rogue, or caster. You will later (at level 5) pick a discipline in which to specialise, which is basically your class. Each base class has three subclasses to choose from.

And if it sounds as though there isn’t a ranged class, think again. Due to the way the skills work, classes have a wide range of skills, Guild Wars style. Just you have to decide which ones you want to slot for any particular situation.

So, for example, my rogue has a full suite of ranged attacks. If I wanted to set her up as an archer type, it would be very easy to do.

You have a wide choice of skin and hair colours and a reasonable range of styles. (My test character is blonde because I was briefly obsessed by trying to make her hair the same pale colour as the skin. I’d have had better luck matching skin and hair if she’d been black. Will do that next time, and there are hairstyles and faces that would look good like that.)

Clothing wise, you are not actually stuck with a standard set of newbie gear. You can design your armour from sets of different parts that you mix and match. Again, don’t read too much into the fact that my test character looks like a scrapheap. The customisation is limited but you do have some scope to pick your own look. The armour is also all dyeable.

If you change your mind about gear later on, as well as being able to pick up drops, you can also buy any of the chargen armour in towns.

Note: every character, regardless of base class, uses the same chargen. This means that you can’t tell from the gear what class someone else is. Yes, casters can use heavy armour and two handed swords if they want. But the gear is largely just for show.

Once happy with that and you have picked a name, you are dropped into the newbie tutorial. This is a little solo instance where you can practice moving around, interacting with NPCs and items, and try a few simple fights.

And then you’re off into the outside world.

Look and Feel

The game uses the Unreal Engine and although the proportions on the characters can look mildly odd, the way they move and fight looks very fluid. The starting area is attractive, and characters fit well into the world. I mention this because in some games the world is gorgeous and the characters feel tacked on, or move so badly that it’s painful to watch.

That isn’t the case here.

Combat!

Combat is what really sets this game apart. There are three main reasons for this:

1/ The reticule. You have to target an enemy in order to hit them. Like a FPS, this is done with a targeting reticule in the middle of your screen. It changes colour to red when it is moving over something which you can attack.

2/ Moving around in combat is important. You can actually duck out of a mob’s melee range to avoid a blow and then run back in. Mobs have to aim at you in order to hit you, so if you are good at moving around, strafing, and so on, you can take almost no damage.

3/ Skill selection. When you go up a level, you can pick one of a number of skills to add to your skill deck (ie. the skill deck is the set of skills you currently know). From your deck, you assign skills to your combat quickbars. You use the mouse or number keys to pick a hotkey and the left mouse button to fire it, while aiming at the enemy. But wait, there’s more. The quickbar is actually a set of three (initially) bars. And after you have used an ability, it rotates to the next bar automatically (after the third bar it goes back to the beginning). So when you assign skills to the quickbars, you have to think about which order you might want to use them in. Does one debuff need to happen before another attack? When might you want a heal to be available? What about ranged attacks?

So once you have set your quickbars up, combat is an involved mixture of selecting abilities, moving around, keeping the enemy targeted, and watching your quickbars rotate to gauge what ability will be available next.

There is also a semi-complex set of buffs and debuffs to add into the mix. Some abilities do more damage if an opponent is debuffed in specific ways.

It takes some practice and I’m not sure I’d ever be good at it, but it is for sure a lot less dull than standing around and hitting frostblast repeatedly.

Meaningful Stats

We’re very used to seeing stats on our character sheets which aren’t very meaningful. They mean something to the game mechanics, sure, but aside from amounts of health, you wouldn’t notice them by looking at characters.

Spellborn isn’t quite like this.

There are three main stats: physique, morale, and concentration. When you go up levels you get some points to assign between there. And as a general rule, warrior classes specialise in physique, rogue classes in concentration, and caster classes in morale. NPCs and mobs have these stats too, and they will affect how they fight.

Physique affects how quickly you move. And since dodging and turning areĀ  important in combat (not to mention running away!), this is one of the more important stats.

Concentration affects your attack speed. In game this means how quickly your quickbar wheel rotates between one attack and the next.

Morale affects how much damage you do.

So for example, a boar in game has low physique. Even if you didn’t know this, you’d see how slowly it turns in combat. Wolves, by comparison, have high physique and are much quicker. So there are subtle differences in mobs that you fight beyond how much health they have and what spells they may or may not cast.

And if you debuff one of these stats on an opponent, you’ll see the effect immediately.

I like this. It’s a nice change from having to squint at little icons to check what debuffs you have up. Although you can do that too.

On the downside, if you get attacked by a pack of mobs who all debuff the same stat, you can end up in some serious trouble. I was able to run away from a load of humanoids who all debuffed my Physique… but I was running very very very slowly. Fortunately I was able to strafe a bit to avoid some of the hits which is how I survived, but it is a bit savage.

Gear in general

Gear is basically cosmetic in this game. But each item has slots into which you can add sigils (ie. thingies with stats, if you find or make them). Don’t expect to know what class someone is just by looking at them.

My summary, from the heights of level 7

I really liked the combat. It felt involving and immersive. Needing to keep the opponent targeted lent the whole thing a very FPS feel, although it really isn’t a first person shooter.

So if you’re looking for something like that from a fantasy MMO, definitely go try Spellborn. I also think the skill deck has the potential for some fairly deep, tactical gameplay. I liked how my rogue could have easily fitted herself out as ranged OR melee dps. Or probably even both, but I’d have to juggle skills around and really decide which I wanted.

At higher levels, this will get more interesting due to longer quickbars, more bars, and more skills to choose from. At low levels though, trying to decide which skill to learn on reaching a new level is quite overwhelming.

It is also bizarre to me that the tutorial stopped just when it was about to get to the complex parts of the combat/quickbar system where a tutorial might actually have been useful.

The newbie quests themselves weren’t very exciting. Kill ten boars cropped up on more than one occasion. But to be honest, I was happy to have something to practice my noob combat skills on, and that’s what the starting quests are all about. There is a definite paucity of mobs in the starting area when lots of other people are questing too. The areas themselves were attractive and once you got past the whole ‘kill ten boars’ness of the quests, they’re written well enough.

In the next zone up I did more exciting things like lead lost cows back to pasture!

The world building and lore that I picked up was intriguing. There are politicking great houses, a world broken into shards, and lots of history that I didn’t really understand. But it was really the combat that I found more enthralling — the starting areas and quests are serviceable but not more than that.

I liked my roguelet well enough, the trickster looks to have a fun bunch of things to do. Sure, I saw casters soloing groups whereas my main experience of soloing groups was ‘how to run away from stuff’, but that could just as easily be my inexperience at strafing around and moving in combat.

I spoke to one guy who had a high level trickster on the EU game and he really liked it. So take that as you wish.

More reviews:

Dragonchaser has a great first impression post here. And for another view, check out Melmoth’s first impressions.

About these ads

11 thoughts on “A little touch of Spellborn in the night

  1. Spooky! Your character and my character are insanely similar in design.

    It’s nice to see mixed opinions on the game across various blogs, it clearly means that there is a market for the game that Spellborn represents.

    A thought: I’m not a raider, never have been, and probably never would be even if I had the time. Whereas you sit firmly on the other side of that fence, as far as I can tell. Does this affect how we view the game? Do you, perhaps, approach it from a more investigative and tolerant viewpoint, being that those are qualities that I imagine a good raider needs to overcome raid boss battles with the intrinsic wipe/rez/retry approach to progress.

    I don’t want this to devolve into a hardcore vs casual thing, it’s not what I’m getting at. I’m just pondering as to whether what I want out of an MMO is actually not what MMOs are capable of delivering, or at least, it’s not what MMOs these days aim to deliver; they deliver the sort of content that the more raiding-minded among us will enjoy.

    Again, I’m not saying that Spellborn has raid-like content, I’m talking about its enjoyment depending on that apparent difference in mindset that exists between those who enjoy raiding and those who find it to be anathema to them.

    • I definitely am very tolerant of flaws in games if I think the fun outweighed them.

      I dunno if it ties into raiding so much, but I love shiny new things and cool game mechanics. So if I’m giving my first impressions, you can be sure I’ll glom onto anything like that and pass briefly over the same-old-same-old. But I really wouldn’t take my first impressions as meaning that what you want isn’t what MMOs deliver (it might be, but I’d need to know more about what you want!). And I also don’t know about Spellborn and raiding.

      I do love puzzle-type games. One of the reasons I like PvE (and, yes, raids) is that I enjoy the challenge of thinking up and executing tactics to beat the puzzle of the encounter. It’s not the only thing I like about MMOs, I love immersive persistent game worlds, but I long since gave up on any MMO giving me the immersion I had in MUSHes.

      But I guess what I wanted to say is that this is really my first impressions. I only levelled one character to level 7 and did a few quests. The things that really stood out to me were the combat stuffs and the way the debuffs worked, so that’s what I wrote about.

      It may appeal to the raid obsessed because combat is a bit more of a minigame here. So figuring out how to optimise your skill deck is likely to be a big part of the game. How big a part I dunno though, it’s just what mostly caught my eye in this first impression.

  2. “Although the temptation to make a Fat Bottomed Girls guild and only let fat characters in, and sing Queen covers as we roam the landscape cutting bloody swathes through our more svelte opponents is quite high.”

    For this, I would try it one more time. Though I’d have to redownload it… and my HD is getting crowded. (Right now, CoX test >> anything else. Mmm Mission Editor.)

    @ Melmoth re: tolerance. I bet it does. I was wondering the same myself as I read it, and thinking maybe I was a little harsh. Maaaaaybe I can learn to play a reticle system. (Though the plain fact is, I’ve been crap at those since … always. This is not a recent thing for me.) I can’t walk, talk and chew gum with a reticle system. :(

  3. Oops Staircase Mind* — I’m still keen to see if we can’t get a bloggers’ static group type thing going in one of these games, even though we don’t really know each other from Adam. You lot sort of help my homesickness for the green and pleasant hills. Also, my timetable is Euro-TZ friendly. Maybe TCOS would be more fun as a community adventure.

    * Where you think of the perfect cutting remark (or really clever comment) only AFTER slamming the door and starting down the stairs. (Or hitting the Submit button.)

    • I don’t honestly know if I’d ever be anything but a liability in Spellborn. I’m not any good at either PvP or FPS games! But I did think the combat was kind of fun, and would be fun to learn your way around.

      The downside for me is that the quests really were quite dull, and I was quite intimidated by the huge list of available skills. It’s not a smooth learning curve.

      Would be fun to hang out somewhere though, I think all these games are pretty cool if you go in with a bunch of friends (or at least people you want to talk to :) ).

  4. I’d definitely be up for a static group, in TCoS or elsewhere. Preferably elsewhere, as I’m not entirely sure about TCoS, as you may perhaps have heard (Hi, I’m Melmoth, you may remember me from such articles as ‘Chronicles of Spellborn: Does it cause cooties?’).

    Still, I’m firmly of the opinion that it’s the fellow players that make an MMO as much as the game itself, so TCoS wouldn’t be off the cards for me, but I’d more likely be there for the companionship than the game in that case.

    I imagine Zoso could be ‘arm-twisted’ into enjoying the company of others too, being that he’s the easy-going amenable one with the competent social skills.

    • There’s always CoX post-update 14 when we can design silly capers for each other. (Am working on one now… I should probably not have started with custom villain groups :P)

      Or whatever else we may all be playing. Speaking of, *is* there a game we’re ALL playing? Premium and/or otherwise.

      Current subs: WoW, CoX

      I probably wouldn’t be averse to LOTRO with friends. Was in LOTRO and Vanguard betas and picked the latter on release. It had a more complex (*snort*) crafting system. ;)

      • Sounds fun :)

        I have current subs to: WoW (EU), WAR (EU), LOTRO (EU — came back for a month to see Moria and forgot to cancel the resub in time so have an extra month now.)

        Would be happy to give CoX a go, or any of the above. With CoX, I’d have to start from scratch though (so could be US or EU). Or even EVE or … I dunno really. Trying out Vanguard or EQ2 with friends could be cool too.

  5. Pingback: A holiday, a holiday, the first one of the year! Best of 2009. « Welcome to Spinksville!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s