This post contains no spoilers

My favourite spoiler story is connected with Harry Potter and the Halfblood Prince. If you have managed to go all of this time without ever learning what the spoiler is for that book then I salute you, and if real life had achievements you’d be up for [Harry Who?]. In any case, as soon as the book was out, so were the spoilers. People plastered them all over bulletin boards, had t-shirts printed (helpfully giving page numbers), blabbed it all over TV shows and … my personal favourite … put up huge banners on motorway bridges telling everyone who passed underneath the secrets of the book.

I’m reliably informed that indigenous tribes on planets in another solar system first learned English by interpreting messages beamed out from NASA about the Harry Potter spoilers. In a millenia’s time, when mankind makes first contact, I won’t be surprised if the first information exchanged by aliens, with a mad snigger, is about Albus Dumbledore.

Now, spoilers are a very personal issue for both geeks and non-geeks alike. You’ll definitely get a very different experience from a book or film or game if someone tells you the shocking twist in advance, but not everyone finds that it totally ruins their enjoyment. I’m fairly relaxed about spoilers myself, for example, but I don’t make a habit of deliberately spoiling twists for other people. (With the shameful exception that I guessed the twist in Sixth Sense about five minutes into the film and told my husband. I don’t think he has entirely forgiven me. My defense is that it was just a guess, I wasn’t SURE.)

In WoW, we’re now quite resigned to spoilers leaking out in advance of new patches. We know that someone (probably someone from mmo-champion) will have datamined the patch from the test server, people on wow.com will have posted all the strategies for new instances from the test server, and it probably won’t be difficult to find out anything else from various forums or twitter. Is it really a problem? You can just avoid the spoiler sites if you don’t want to learn too much.

In a surprising move on the official forums, Nethaera posted a comment this week implying that Blizzard do see it as an issue and disapprove of sites posting data-mined content:

We’ve put thousands of hours of work into crafting an epic conclusion to the Wrath of the Lich King story, and we’re excited that we’ll soon be able to share it with everyone — however, we also think the surprises we’ve got in store are best experienced within the context of the game itself. Should you wish not to have your Icecrown experience spoiled, we advise you to steer clear of any sites data-mining and posting this content. And if you do seek out spoilers, we ask that you please be mindful of your fellow players on the official forums. We’re looking forward to hearing about your adventures once the new content is available on the live realms.

Rumour has it that they have also exerted some IP influence to have spoiler related clips taken off youtube.

I can’t say I’m sorry to see it. I do find it frustrating that just because people are off testing the new patches (which is good) they feel they have to spoil it for everyone else. I just don’t see that it can ever be stopped, as long as lots of people really do want to get that slight advantage that the knowledge might give them. wow.com aren’t going to stop posting data-mined content, it must get them a ton of search hits every day.

But perhaps it’s not asking too much to have RSS feeds for people who don’t want their content spoiled, or to mark the spoilers a little more clearly…

About these ads

6 thoughts on “This post contains no spoilers

  1. re: “mark the spoilers a little more clearly…”

    Frankly, you could have go-go boys with “Spoiler” painted in flashing text on the bums on the forwarding page that people must go through to view the content and it would still be “not clearly marked enough” for some people.

    As for books – the best fiction can survive multiple readings. Considering how many times some of us are going to have to experience the “story” of Icecrown, I would hope that it can survive the experience of me getting to read and see it as a narrative instead of between listening to/reading/watching videos of the boss strategies.

  2. I managed to go without finding out the ending of the Usual Suspects before my first watching of it and I’ve loved it ever since. Conversely, I know the ending to the 6th Sense and so cannot watch the thing (I’ve tried), as the film just seems to be all about that twist at the end, knowing the twist at the start makes the film dull and uninteresting.

  3. Kudos! I was going to write a post about this topic but you have beaten me too it.

    My problem is a little different. I want spoilers about some things but not about others. For example, I want to know the spoilers about anything regarding professions so I can plan my AH strategy. But I don’t what to know the spoilers about plot or anything else. So my problem with MMO-Champion and WoW.com is that they mix it all together. In order to get to the stuff I want to know, I have to sort thought all the stuff I don’t want to learn about. Gah!

    • Is it selfish if I hope you do go ahead and write it, because I like your writing and would love to see your thoughts.

      I still can’t help wondering how excited we’d have been about Cataclysm if that announcement hadn’t been leaked. Would not knowing those spoilers have made the experience more fun for everyone involved?

      But on the other hand, as you say, there is a big in-game advantage to be had from having more information than other people about what’s coming up.

  4. I’m generally in the camp of not worrying about spoilers. As long as people warn others so they can be selective, I’m good with it.

    Mixing spoilers? A little more tricky to manage.

  5. In FFXI they often had it up before the updated content went live. Yeah that’s right, before you could even get into the game because servers were down for the updating, people had managed to DAT mine NPC text. While they didn’t post spoiler related stories, you could easily know what to do to trigger missions or even the rewards for a whole mission line before the game went live. They did it by some hackery I cant explain fully-delete a file, run file check, and the expansion would download too.

    Story spoilers didn’t bother me as much as the huge spoilers of gear, or new areas. There was no real surprise unless you closed your eyes to every forum post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s